Check the source folder first: did the game actually write a replay, and is the file still changing? A live or half-written artifact is not ready for judgment.

Check the watcher state next. Confirm it is pointed at the HD replay location you are using, not the location you used six months and one reinstall ago. Then check whether the game finalized normally; disconnects and abrupt exits can produce different evidence.

Finally, check the upload or parse surface for the filename and time. If it still has not arrived, report the filename, approximate finish time, and what the watcher showed. “It is broken” creates a mystery. Three concrete facts create a trail.